SignUpGenius alternative: a free sign-up sheet on Google Forms
Google Forms plus a slot-limiting add-on does the sign-up sheet job for free: each shift, dish or time slot gets a capacity, full options drop off the form, and a waitlist takes the overflow. The form stays on your own link, shows no ads, and every response lands in your Google Drive instead of on someone else's site. What you give up versus SignUpGenius is the hosted page and whatever it bundles around it, so this is a trade, not a free lunch.
I run sign-ups this way for workshops and school events, and I built the add-on in question, so read the Form Slots section with that in mind. The rest of the page holds up whether or not you install anything.
Why people look for a SignUpGenius alternative
SignUpGenius is a hosted sign-up sheet tool with slots built in. You make the sheet on their site, hand out their link, and people claim a slot. It works. The complaints I hear are about the same few things. The free sign-ups show ads, and your parents and volunteers see them. The link is theirs, so your PTA or studio sends people to signupgenius.com rather than to something that looks like yours. And the names, emails and choices live on their site, which bothers anyone who already keeps everything in Google Drive. For current prices and what each tier includes, check their pricing page. I am not going to quote numbers that may be stale by the time you read this.
Who should stay on SignUpGenius
Be honest with yourself before switching. Stay if:
- You do not use Google Workspace and have no interest in starting. The whole case for the Forms route is that you already live in Drive.
- You want a hosted page that does more than collect names. If reminder emails before the event matter to you, check what SignUpGenius includes on its pricing page, because Google Forms plus Form Slots sends confirmation and waitlist emails, not reminders.
- Your organizers are many and they rotate. A hosted tool with one obvious way to do things can be easier to hand over than a form with an add-on the next person has to know about.
If none of those apply, the setup below takes about ten minutes.
Set up a free sign-up sheet in Google Forms (6 steps)
Google Forms on its own has no per-option limit. It accepts the fifteenth volunteer for a shift with room for four and tells you nothing. The add-on is what turns a form into a sheet with slots. I built Form Slots for exactly this. Free covers one live form at a time with every feature, and Pro ($6/month or $49/year) is for running several live forms at once.
- Create the form. Add one multiple-choice, dropdown or checkbox question and make one option per slot: "Saturday 9-11am", "Saturday 11am-1pm", and so on. Grid questions are not supported, so stick to those three types.
- Open Settings and turn on "Collect email addresses". The waitlist and the confirmation emails need it. Without it the caps still work, but nobody gets emailed and there is no queue.
- Click the Add-ons puzzle icon, choose Form Slots, then Configure slots, and pick the question.
- Type a capacity next to each option. "Set all slots to" fills them all at once when every slot takes the same number.
- Turn the waitlist on, then Save & activate.
- Share the form's normal link, or download the QR code from the sidebar. There is no hosted copy and no second URL.
From then on, when an option fills it is removed from the live form, usually within a minute. The person who took the last seat gets a confirmation email from Form Slots (notifications@mail.formslots.com, never from your account). Anyone who arrives after the cap is waitlisted and told so. When a seat opens, because you deleted a response or raised the limit, the next person in line is confirmed and emailed without you doing anything. Bookings are decided on Form Slots' own server, one at a time per form, so two people who submit in the same second cannot both get the last seat. The sidebar shows booked, waiting and a FULL badge per option, which is the closest thing to the overview a hosted sheet gives you.
The longer version, with the form layout choices, is in the Google Forms sign-up sheet guide.
SignUpGenius vs Google Forms vs Google Forms + Form Slots
| SignUpGenius | Google Forms alone | Google Forms + Form Slots | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Slot caps | Yes, built in | No | Yes, per option, full options hidden |
| Waitlist | Check their pricing page | No | Yes, automatic, next person emailed |
| Ads | On free sign-ups | None | None |
| Your link | Their link | Your form's link and QR | Same form link and QR |
| Where data lives | On their site | Your Google Drive | Your Google Drive |
| Price | See pricing page | Free | Free for one live form, Pro $6/month or $49/year |
One row deserves a note. "Where data lives" is the reason most people make the switch, and it cuts both ways. Responses in Drive are yours to sort, share and keep. They are also yours to protect, so check who has edit access to the form before you send the link to a hundred parents.
Common sign-up sheets and how to model them in a form
Volunteer shifts
One multiple-choice question, one option per shift, capacity equal to the number of helpers you need. If the same person can take two shifts, use a checkbox question instead. When someone ticks three shifts and only two have room, two are confirmed and the third goes to the waitlist, in a single email.
Potluck
Options are the dishes or categories ("Main", "Salad", "Dessert", "Drinks") with a cap on each, so you do not end up with nine desserts and no salad. A short-answer question underneath for "what are you bringing" keeps the responses readable. I set the caps a little above what I need, because potluck sign-ups always have a no-show or two.
Parent-teacher conferences
Options are the time slots, each with a capacity of 1. Collect email addresses so a parent who changes their mind and resubmits replaces the first slot rather than holding two. If you need different questions per teacher, use "Go to section based on answer". The routing keeps working when a full slot is hidden.
Class seats
One option per class, capacity equal to the seats, waitlist on. If you run intake in rounds, Reset backs up every response to a new Google Sheet before clearing the form, so the next round starts clean and the last one is still there. If the order people signed up in matters, first come first served in Google Forms covers the fairness side, and the waitlist guide goes deeper on the queue.
What you give up
There is no hosted page. People see a Google Form, which is plainer than a dedicated sign-up sheet page. There are no reminder emails before the event. And Form Slots is new, with no install count to point at. If the hosted page is what you are paying for, stay and pay for it. If what you need is slots, a queue, your own link and your own data, the form does it for nothing.
Questions people ask
Is Google Forms a free alternative to SignUpGenius?
Yes, with one add-on. Google Forms itself cannot cap a slot, so a sheet with limits needs an add-on such as Form Slots. The Free plan runs one live form at a time with every feature included.
Can Google Forms limit sign-ups per slot?
Not natively. Google Forms can limit the whole form to one response per person and stop accepting responses by hand. A per-option cap, where a full shift or time slot disappears from the form, needs an add-on.
Does a Google Forms sign-up sheet show ads?
No. A Google Form shows no ads, and Form Slots adds none. SignUpGenius shows ads on free sign-ups.
Can people join a waitlist when a slot is full?
Yes. With Form Slots, anyone who submits after a slot fills is waitlisted and emailed. When a seat opens, the next person in line is confirmed automatically. The form needs Settings > Collect email addresses turned on.
Where do the sign-ups go?
Into your form's responses in Google Drive, like any other Google Form. Form Slots only reads the form it is installed in and does not copy your data anywhere else. With SignUpGenius the data lives on their site.