Guides

Choice Eliminator 2 alternatives: what the clones share and what to use instead

Choice Eliminator 2 was the Google Forms add-on that removed an answer once it hit a limit, so a "Tuesday 10 am" slot vanished from the form when the twelfth person picked it. Search for it today and you mostly land on clones: Choice Eliminator Lite, 3, 4 and 5. They do the same job the same way, with the same weak spot on busy forms. The alternatives worth a look are CAPY, Skyfield Form Limiter, Everest Form Choice Limiter and Form Slots, and which one fits depends on how fast your form fills up.

What people are actually looking for

About 720 searches a month worldwide still ask for "Choice Eliminator 2". Almost nobody wants that exact add-on. They want the thing it did: a capacity on each option of a multiple-choice or dropdown question, and the option gone from the form once the capacity is reached. Parent-teacher conferences, lab time slots, volunteer shifts, a workshop with 12 chairs.

Google Forms cannot do this on its own. The native settings stop at "Limit to 1 response", "Collect email addresses" and the manual "Accepting responses" toggle. So the question that matters is which add-on does this job now, and how well.

What happened to the Choice Eliminator family

I installed everything with the name on it in July 2026. Here is what I saw.

Choice Eliminator Lite (Accemy & SW gApps) has the biggest number, 2.89M+ installs, and a rating around 3 stars. When I tried it in July 2026 it could not be installed at all. Its developer describes it as a tool for light use, and the reviews read like people who used it for heavy use.

Choice Eliminator 3, 4 and 5 come from 2HAC Studio LLC and sit around 4.6 stars. They install and they work. What bothered me is the consent screen: to limit one question on one form, you grant permission to see, edit, create and delete all your Google Sheets and all the forms in your Drive. On a school account that is a conversation with IT.

Lite and 3 through 5 all run on Google Apps Script triggers. That matters more than the number after the name.

The problem every trigger-based tool shares

A trigger runs after Google Forms has already saved the response. The add-on wakes up, counts how many people picked each option, and if a count reached the limit it edits the form to hide that option. Fine when sign-ups trickle in. Not fine when they arrive in a burst.

Picture one seat left in the Thursday slot. Two parents press Submit within the same second. Google saves both responses, because at that moment the form still shows Thursday. The trigger fires, counts 13 bookings on a 12-seat slot, and removes Thursday from the form. Too late. Both parents are looking at a confirmation screen, and you have an awkward email to write.

This is not a bug in one product. Skyfield's reviews mention 1 or 2 responses over capacity on busy forms. Everest's FAQ admits that options with identical text can overbook. CAPY has the same timing because it uses the same mechanism. The trigger also runs under your Google account, so each of these tools needs permission to "run when you are not present". I wrote up the usual failure modes in why your choice eliminator stopped working.

Alternatives worth considering

These are the four I would shortlist. Install counts and ratings are what I saw in July 2026. I have not verified every price, so where I am not sure the table says so.

Add-onHow it decides a bookingWaitlistConsent and accessFree tierPrice
CAPY (AddonForge), 1M+ installs, 4.88Trigger after the response is savedNoAll your Google Sheets (edit and delete) plus the forms it is installed inSee listingSee listing
Skyfield Form Limiter, 1M+ installs, 4.91Trigger after the response is saved, scheduler in 1-hour stepsNot that I foundCleanest scopes of the trigger group, still runs under your accountSee listingSee listing
Everest Form Choice Limiter, 1M+ installs, 4.86Trigger after the response is savedNot that I foundRuns under your accountSee listingSee listing
Form Slots, newOn its own server, one booking at a time per form, before the seat is givenYes, automatic, with emailsOnly the form it is installed in, no triggersOne live form, every feature$6/month or $49/year

A few notes the table cannot hold. Skyfield has the highest rating of the group, but its reset deletes responses, so export first, and its trigger limit works out to about 10 forms per account. Everest emails you on every click on a closed option, which the reviews are not fond of. CAPY bundles an AI quiz maker you may or may not want. The full five-way breakdown is in the choice eliminator comparison.

When a trigger-based tool is fine, and when it is not

If your form fills over days, a trigger-based add-on is fine. Twenty volunteer slots, a link sent to a staff mailing list, replies dribbling in all week. The lag between a slot filling and the option disappearing never bites, because nobody is competing for the same seat at the same moment. In that case I would pick Skyfield for the ratings and the lighter consent screen.

It is not fine when demand arrives all at once. A link to 300 families at 7 pm, or a ticketed event where an extra body means an extra chair you do not have. There, a popular slot will almost certainly take one extra, and you will spend the next morning sorting it out by hand.

Form Slots, the one built without triggers

I built Form Slots because I kept hitting that after-the-fact problem. It does not use Google Forms triggers. Each booking is decided on Form Slots' own server, one at a time per form, so two people submitting in the same second cannot both get the last seat. When an option fills it is removed from the live form, usually within a minute, and it comes back if a response is deleted or you raise the limit.

The piece I use most is the waitlist. When a slot is full, extra sign-ups wait in line. If a seat opens, the next person is confirmed automatically and gets an email from Form Slots, not from your account. That needs the form setting "Collect email addresses". Without it the limits still work, you just get no waitlist and no emails. The same setting lets a person who submits twice replace their old answer instead of taking two seats.

Access is narrow on purpose: Form Slots can only see the form it is installed in. No other Drive files, no email, no "run when you are not present" scope. It is new, so there is no install count to point at, and the Free plan covers one live form at a time with every feature. Pro is $6 a month or $49 a year for unlimited live forms, details on the pricing page.

How to switch without resending the link

  1. Turn off or uninstall the old add-on on that form, so two tools are not editing the same question.
  2. Open the form editor and go to Add-ons (puzzle icon) > Form Slots > Configure slots.
  3. Pick the question, type a capacity for each option (there is a "Set all slots to" shortcut), then Save & activate.
  4. If you want the waitlist, turn on Settings > "Collect email addresses".
  5. Keep the same form link and QR code. There is no hosted copy and no second URL, so nothing to resend.

Existing responses stay where they are. More on how the queue behaves in the waitlist guide.

Questions people ask

Is Choice Eliminator 2 still available?

Searches for it mostly land on clones: Choice Eliminator Lite, 3, 4 and 5. Lite could not be installed when I tried it in July 2026. The 3, 4 and 5 versions by 2HAC Studio install and work, but ask for access to all your Google Sheets and forms.

Why do choice eliminators let one extra person through?

They run on Google Forms triggers, which fire after the response is already saved. If two people submit on the last seat in the same second, both responses are stored before the option is removed.

Which Choice Eliminator alternative has the cleanest permissions?

Among trigger-based tools, Skyfield Form Limiter asks for the least. Form Slots only touches the form it is installed in and uses no triggers at all.

Do I need to send a new form link when I switch?

No. Form Slots works on the form's normal link and QR code. Install it, set capacities on the same question, and the link you already shared keeps working.

Is there a free option?

Form Slots Free covers one live form at a time with every feature, including the waitlist. For the other add-ons, check their Marketplace listings, pricing changes often.