CAPY alternatives: when the best choice eliminator is not the right one
CAPY (Choice Eliminator, Form Limiter, AI) is the best of the rebuilt choice eliminators for Google Forms: 1M+ installs, a 4.88 rating, and when I tested it in July 2026 it did what it says. People look for an alternative for four reasons. The consent screen asks for edit and delete access to every Google Sheet in your Drive, the trigger timing lets a seat or two slip through on a busy form, it bundles an AI quiz maker most sign-up forms never use, and it has no waitlist. The alternatives worth comparing are Skyfield Form Limiter, Everest Form Choice Limiter and Form Slots.
Credit where it is due
CAPY is made by AddonForge (addonforge.com). Of the add-ons that took over from Choice Eliminator 2, it is the one I would hand to a colleague without a warning label. The sidebar is clear and option removal works. If your form fills over a week and your account is your own, you can probably stay on it. The rest of this page is for the people who hit one of the four problems below.
Why people look elsewhere
The consent screen
To limit one question on one form, CAPY asks to see, edit, create and delete all your Google Sheets, plus the forms it is installed in. I do not think there is anything sinister going on. It is how trigger-based add-ons are usually built, and the Sheets access is there because responses live in a Sheet. But on a school or company account the admin will ask why a sign-up tool needs delete rights on every spreadsheet, and "that is how it was built" is not a satisfying answer.
Trigger timing on busy forms
CAPY runs on Google Apps Script triggers. A trigger fires after Google has already saved the response. The add-on then counts, notices a slot is full, and hides the option. On a slow form the gap does not matter. On a form sent to 300 families at 7 pm it does. One seat left, two parents press Submit in the same second, both responses are stored because the form still showed the slot to both, and the count lands at 13 on a 12-seat slot. Skyfield's reviews describe exactly this, 1 or 2 responses over capacity, and the mechanism is identical across the trigger group. More on the failure modes in why your choice eliminator stopped working.
The bundled AI quiz maker
The "AI" in the name is a quiz generator. If you run quizzes, nice. If you run parent-teacher conferences, it is a tab you ignore, and it is part of why the add-on asks for as much as it does. Some people would rather install a tool that only does the one thing.
No waitlist
When a slot fills, CAPY hides it. The person who arrives a minute later sees the remaining options or nothing. There is no queue, no "we will email you if a seat opens". For most sign-up forms the waitlist is the feature people email me about after the first round, because seats always open up and refilling them by hand is tedious.
Alternatives compared
Install counts and ratings are from July 2026. Where I have not verified a price, the table says so rather than guessing.
| Add-on | How it decides a booking | Waitlist | Consent and access | Free tier | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Skyfield Form Limiter, 1M+ installs, 4.91 | Trigger after the response is saved, scheduler in 1-hour steps | Not that I found | Cleanest scopes of the trigger group, still runs under your account | See listing | See listing |
| Everest Form Choice Limiter, 1M+ installs, 4.86 | Trigger after the response is saved | Not that I found | Runs under your account | See listing | See listing |
| Form Slots, new | On its own server, one booking at a time per form, before the seat is given | Yes, automatic, with emails | Only the form it is installed in, no triggers | One live form, every feature | $6/month or $49/year |
Skyfield is the obvious trigger-based swap: highest rating of the group, the lightest consent screen, a response-limit and date close, and a QR code. Two things to know. Its reset deletes responses, so export first, and it pauses elimination on questions that use "go to section" branching. Everest works but emails you on every click on a closed option, editing an option's text resets its count, and its own FAQ admits that removing options breaks "go to section" routing. The five-way breakdown with Choice Eliminator 3 included is in the choice eliminator comparison.
Form Slots, the non-trigger option
I built Form Slots after running into the timing problem one too many times. It does not use Google Forms triggers. Bookings are decided on Form Slots' own server, one at a time per form, before the respondent is given the seat. Two people submitting in the same second cannot both take the last one, so per option it never overbooks. The full option is removed from the live form usually within a minute, and comes back if you delete a response or raise the limit.
It has the waitlist CAPY lacks. Turn on "Collect email addresses" and extra sign-ups wait in line, first come first served. When a seat opens, the next person is confirmed automatically and emailed from Form Slots, never from your account, only about their own booking. If the same person submits twice, the new answer replaces the old one instead of taking two seats. "Go to section" routing keeps working when an option is hidden. Without email collection the limits still work, you just lose the waitlist. The queue is explained in the waitlist guide.
On access: Form Slots only sees the form it is installed in. No other Drive files, no email, no triggers, no "run when you are not present" scope. It is new, so there is no install count to compare with CAPY's million. Free covers one live form at a time with every feature. Pro is $6 a month or $49 a year for unlimited live forms, see pricing. Setup is Add-ons (puzzle icon) > Form Slots > Configure slots > pick the question > capacity per option > Save & activate. Grid questions are not supported.
If you stay on CAPY, do this
Plenty of forms do not need to move. If yours is one of them, a few habits make the trigger timing mostly harmless.
- Set each capacity one or two under the real number. If the room holds 12, cap the option at 10 or 11. An overbook then lands on a chair you actually have.
- When a popular slot is close to full, watch the responses and flip "Accepting responses" off yourself if you see a rush coming. The manual toggle beats the trigger every time.
- Turn on "Limit to 1 response" if your respondents have Google accounts. It stops the same person booking two seats, which no trigger can do after the fact.
- Check the responses sheet the morning after a big send. If a slot shows one extra, you want to know before the confirmations go out, not at the door.
- Do not rename an option mid-round unless you have checked how CAPY handles it. Everest resets the count on a rename, and I would not assume any trigger-based tool treats a renamed option as the same one.
If you find yourself doing the second and fourth items every round, that is the point where I would switch. Until then, CAPY is a fine tool and the rating is deserved. For the bigger picture, native settings included, see first come first served in Google Forms.
Questions people ask
Is CAPY a good choice eliminator for Google Forms?
Yes. With 1M+ installs and a 4.88 rating it is the best of the rebuilt choice eliminators. The reasons to look elsewhere are its consent screen, the trigger timing on busy forms, the bundled AI quiz maker and the lack of a waitlist.
Why does CAPY ask for access to all my Google Sheets?
It runs on Google Apps Script triggers and its consent screen asks to see, edit and delete all your Google Sheets plus the forms it is installed in. That is how it was built, not a sign of bad intent, but it is more access than a sign-up form needs.
Can CAPY overbook a slot?
On a busy form, yes, by one or two. The check runs after the response is saved, so two people submitting on the last seat in the same second can both get through. On a slow form it is rarely a problem.
Which CAPY alternative has a waitlist?
Form Slots. When a slot is full, extra sign-ups wait in line and the next person is confirmed and emailed automatically when a seat opens. It needs the form setting Collect email addresses.
Can I keep my form link when I switch from CAPY?
Yes. Form Slots and the other add-ons here work on the form's normal link and QR code. Turn CAPY off on that question, install the new add-on, set the capacities and the link keeps working.